iskyo aronov million dollar listing

Another got swindled out of a $500,000 college fund. (See Ind. Heather's Instagram is filled with beautiful homes in the LA area that range from $1.6 million to well over $15 million. As alleged, the defendants defrauded mortgage loan holders out of millions of dollars, with taxpayers saddled with much of the loss, stated United States Attorney Donoghue. Michael Herskowitz Age: 40 Brooklyn, New York 28(d), and likewise, with respect to 2403 Dean Street, he is only "alleged to have wired the payoff amount and sale proceeds to two bank accounts on the date of closing," (id. 14.) (quoting De La Pava, 268 F.3d at 162)). For starters, Million Dollar Listing LA star Josh Flagg made the Hollywood Reporter 's Top 30 L.A. 2012) ("[A] federal indictment can be challenged on the ground that it fails to allege a crime within the terms of the applicable statute." As for Steve Gold, the realtor set a brand new Husdon Yards . ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. He was taking care of everybody. on Sept. 19. The buildings were on blocks where all my rich friends lived, recalled one insider who lost $200,000. In turn, HUD paid the lenders claims for FHA insurance from federal funds. The Indictment further alleges that Herskowitz "assisted the Short-Sale Co-Conspirators in completing certain fraudulent short sale transactions originated by both MIP and Exclusive Homes," (id. We are always seeking enthusiastic team members to help enhance and enlarge our content for and about Brooklyn. (Def. Aronov was the founder, CEO and president of defendants My Ideal Property Inc., My Ideal Property Group LLC and MIP Management Inc., and also controlled other affiliated corporate entities that he allegedly established to help him fraudulently acquire residential properties, according to the complaint. Million Dollar Listing 's Matt Altman Spotted Out With Wife After Her Domestic Violence Arrest August 18, 2022 Wife of Million Dollar Listing 's Matt Altman Arrested and Charged with Domestic. 28, 28(d), 32, 32(f)), the Indictment also states that Aronov, Konstantinovskiy, and Tarshish, "together with others, worked on fraudulent short sales coordinated by Aronov," to the primary benefit of MIP, (Ind. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. The scam in Monday's lawsuit caused millions of dollars in damages to the Federal Housing Administration since the men would file false or misleading documents so the sales would be approved by the federal government, prosecutors said. Iskyo Aronov ( also known as "Isaac Aronov ") Middle Village, New York, Ron Borovinsky, Hollis Hills, New York and Michael Konstantinovskiy, Roslyn Heights, New York have been charged in a wide-ranging mortgage fraud scheme to defraud the government. On Aug. 30, he was arrested in his Upper East Side home, where law enforcers found a firearm and $44,000 in cash. What makes their alleged crimes even more egregious was their artificial devaluation of properties that, when resold or flipped, resulted in large profits. 2019) (defining bank fraud). Love Brooklyn? 36-39), Count Four (wire fraud in furtherance of the MIP and Exclusive Homes Schemes), Count Six (wire fraud in furtherance of the Exclusive Homes Scheme), and Count Seven (wore fraud in furtherance of the MIP and Exclusive Homes Schemes), (see Id. 175-1.) Aronov wt al, 1:19-cr-00408 Brought to you by the RECAP Initiative and Free Law Project, a non-profit dedicated to creating high quality open legal information. as Ex. From December 2012 to January 2019, Iskyo Aronov, Michael Konstantinovskiy, Tomer Dafna, Avraham Tarshish and . Court Reporter/Transcriber David R. Roy, Telephone number (718) 613-2609. Contact Lisa Riordan Seville at [email protected]. As alleged in the complaint, from at least 2013 through 2016, the defendants defrauded HUD by manipulating the short sale process to acquire residential properties from numerous distressed homeowners for below-fair market value prices in non-arms-length transactions. A lock ( 25). 15-CV-611, 2017 WL 237651, at *5 (S.D.N.Y. Here, the defendants fraudulently manipulated the short sale process by transferring properties for prices well above the short sale prices, and failing to disclose this to the mortgage lenders and servicers. See Raniere, 384 F.Supp.3d at 300 ("[Arguments which concern the sufficiency and/or truth of the allegations in the [c]omplaint, raise factual questions not appropriate for decision on a pretrial motion to dismiss." But the checks arrived like clockwork even as it seemed too good to be true. Make your practice more effective and efficient with Casetexts legal research suite. Iskyo Aronov Represented by. Lisa Riordan Seville is an independent reporter based in Brooklyn, New York. Please complete the form below and click on SIGN UP to receive daily e-newsletters from. He said he had officially hit "rock bottom" after almost passing out at a Phish concert in 2015. 's Mot.,, Docket Entry No. Million Dollar Listing Los Angeles has undergone a cast shakeup. ), The Indictment specifies seven "select transactions" that Defendants and the Short Sale Co-Conspirators executed as part of the Short Sale Schemes, involving properties located at: 175 Vernon Avenue, Brooklyn, New York; 1219 Jefferson Avenue, Brooklyn, New York; 1319 Jefferson Avenue, Brooklyn, New York; 1055 Herkimer Street, Brooklyn, New York; 177 Lewis Avenue, Brooklyn, New York; 2403 Dean Street, Brooklyn, New York; and 65 Glen Street, Brooklyn, New York. Michael Konstantinovskiy (also known as "Michael Kay") Age: 33 Rego Park, Queens. Many of the affected mortgage loans were insured by the Federal Housing Administration, or owned or guaranteed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. 8. United States v. Stringer, 730 F.3d 120, 124 (2d Cir. R. Crim. . Since 2006, the Bravo reality show Million Dollar Listing has been showing viewers the ups and downs of realtors who work with wealthy clients in Los Angeles. MARGO K. BRODIE, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE, On April 29, 2019, a grand jury returned an indictment against Defendants Iskyo Aronov, Michael Konstantinovskiy, Tomer Dafna, Avraham Tarshish, and Michael Herskowitz, charging them with conspiracy to commit wire and bank fraud in violation of 18 U.S.C. (Id. The Indictment identifies Herskowitz as "a real estate attorney who assisted the Short-Sale Co-Conspirators in completing certain fraudulent short sale transactions originated by both MIP and Exclusive Homes." Jan. 18, 2017))). UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, v. ISKYO ARONOV, MICHAEL KONSTANTINOVSKIY, TOMER DAFNA, AVRAHAM TARSHISH, and MICHAEL HERSKOWITZ, Defendants. An indictment was unsealed today in federal court in Brooklyn charging Iskyo Aronov, Michael Konstantinovskiy, Tomer Dafna, Avraham Tarshish and Michael Herskowitz with conspiracy to commit wire fraud and bank fraud, and related wire fraud counts, in connection with a scheme to defraud mortgage lenders, including the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae), the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac) and borrowers. 1083 LAFAYETTE AVE. LLC. ("Counts One and Two"), and substantive counts of wire fraud related to specific transactions in violation of 18 U.S.C. Then in late 2017, investors received emails from DAlessio, claiming that rising development costs and a rocky real estate market meant there would be no payments for the time being. Finally, the Court rejects Herskowitz's argument that Count One should be dismissed because he is not consistently identified as "one of those involved in the MIP Scheme." In the process, they made a host of material misrepresentations in critical transaction documents. Ask anything about Brooklyn. Still, at least one investor has sympathy. Thu 30 December 2021 15:38. The Indictment also charges Herskowitz with substantive wire fraud counts for wire transfers associated with the purchase of 1219 Jefferson Avenue, 2403 Dean Street, and 177 Lewis Avenue. 19, 28, 28(d), 32, 32(f). BuzzFeed News found at least 12 lawsuits in which borrowers said they had been deceived by the group. According to prosecutors, DAlessio was charged with funneling some $58 million money that should have been used for renovations through a network of more than 200 bank accounts. At least 20 people have been convicted in alleged scams. The four other men were arraigned in Brooklyn. 2013) (quoting United States v. De La Pava, 268 F.3d 157, 162 (2d Cir. Official websites use .gov The United States has filed a civil complaint in federal court in Brooklyn seeking damages and penalties against three individuals and multiple companies alleged to have engaged in a wide-ranging mortgage fraud scheme to defraud the government. The father of five picked up tabs at fancy Italian restaurants and doted on his disabled daughter. He's not only handsome, but he's also one of the most successful brokers in New York. We've received your submission. Viewers will get to see the big celebrity homes in the upcoming season of the reality show. 2017) (alteration in original) (quoting United States v. Pirro, 212 F.3d 86, 92 (2d Cir. The proceeds from the short sale, less approved closing costs, are applied to the outstanding mortgage loan balance owed to the lender, who typically agrees to forgive the borrowers remaining mortgage loan balance. The reality star has been spending most of her time selling LA mansions since season 12 wrapped. A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States. ("Def. Many fans have already claimed that they won't be tuning into the show now that he is gone. 9845 86. 31(e), 42)). On today's episode of Just the Sip, Million Dollar Listing Los Angeles star Tracy Tutor revealed how her reality TV career indirectly played a part in her divorce from Jason Maltas. According to court documents, one couple lost $100,000 that was earmarked to aid an ill relative. This allowed them to buy the properties for below-fair market value prices, obtain broker fees, and induce lenders to release the FHA-insured mortgages at a loss. Roslyn Heights, New York, John Marzulli With regard to Counts Two, Four and Seven, Herskowitz contends that "the Indictment alleges only that [he] wired payoff and/or proceeds funds at the closing after all the arrangements for the sale had been made by others," but does not indicate that "he participated in or even that he was told of the short sale arrangements - instead, the allegations are that he simply showed up at the closing and conducted funds transfers as any closing agent would." ISKYO ARONOV (also known as "Isaac Aronov") Age: 32 Miami, Florida. In the mortgage scam, the men, under a company called My Ideal Property Group, manipulated the short sale so they were controlling almost every step of the process, prosecutors said. f 12. Title 18, United States Code, Section 1343 imposes criminal liability on any party who "having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining money or property by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises, transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire in interstate or foreign commerce, any writings for the purpose of executing such scheme or artifice." Join Facebook to connect with Isaac Aronov and others you may know. Aronov was the founder, Chief Executive Officer and President of defendants My Ideal Property Inc., My Ideal Propery Group LLC and MIP Management Inc., and also controlled other affiliated corporate entities that he allegedly established to help him fraudulently acquire residential properties. . Submit your question here. According to the indictment, between December 2012 and January 2019, the defendants conspired to defraud mortgage lenders, misleading them into approving short sale transactions at fraudulently depressed prices. Borovinsky identified himself as a co-founder with Aronov of My Ideal Property. As alleged, these defendants fraudulently obtained homes at depressed prices at the expense of a taxpayer-funded program designed to assist borrowers seeking the American Dream of home ownership, stated Acting U.S. Attorney Seth DuCharme. of Def. Then, with the original owners gone, the partners performed fast gut renovations, installing modern fixtures and marble counters, and resold the homes for north of a million dollars. These payments by HUD were artificially inflated as a result of the defendants fraudulent conduct. A locked padlock Million Dollar Listing's Fredrik Eklund splashes out $7M on 5-bed, 8-bath mansion in Beverly Hills. P. 12(b)(3)(B); United States v. Aleynikov, 676 F.3d 71, 75-76 (2d Cir. A lock ( As alleged in the complaint, from at least 2013 through 2016, the defendants defrauded HUD by manipulating the short sale process to acquire residential properties from numerous distressed homeowners for below-fair market value prices in non-arms-length transactions. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks for contacting us. Aronov appeared in court in Miami and his bond was set at $500,000, according to court papers. ff 32, 32(f)). Tyler Whitman of "Million Dollar Listing: New York" has experienced quite the transformation during his time on the hit reality series. The five men are charged with conspiracy to commit wire and bank fraud for allegedly misleading mortgage companies into approving short sales at fraudulently depressed prices . 14.) Collectively & continuously publishing for more than 400 years. (Id.) An eight-count indictment was unsealed today in federal court in Brooklyn charging Marat Lerner, president of the Lerner Group, with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud, and money laundering , [Marat Lerner], Lerner Group, With todays sentence, Edward Bohm has been deservedly punished for his role in a fraudulent scheme that deceived banks that trusted and relied upon him as a business partner. It's no secret that Josh's wife is incredibly successful when it comes to real estate, but there is one thing . The governments case is being handled by Assistant United States Attorney Michael J. Castiglione, with assistance from Affirmative Civil Enforcement Auditor Michael Gambrell. I need the fking money! recalled the insider. 's Reply in Supp. Million Dollar Listing follows the lives of three of America's hottest, young, and aggressive real estate magnates in the making as they make a fortune selling multi-million dollar properties in . The charges in the indictment are allegations, and the defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. Returning for season 13 are powerhouse agents: Josh Flagg, Josh Altman, Tracy Tutor, James Harris and David Parnes. Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date with the world of mortgage. People reported that Tutor was parting with her seven-bedroom, ten-bathroom home in L.A.'s posh Brentwood neighborhood and was asking an eye-popping $23.9 million. While Brooklyn has become the epitome of cool and hip in recent years, for those that were born here, raised families here and improved communities over the years, Brooklyn has never been uncool. Break up the boys club. Million Dollar Listing New York S03. ), The Government argues that the Indictment is sufficient to put Herskowitz on notice as to the crimes charged in conjunction with his alleged involvement in the Exclusive Homes Scheme, including that he "wired funds to [the loan servicer in order to] complete three of the fraudulent short sale examples described in the Indictment," and "that the loan servicer, in violation of the short sale conditions it had imposed, was not told of the actual purchase price or the amounts paid to the Short Sale Co-Conspirators." "[C]ommon sense and reason are more important than technicalities" and the indictment "need not be perfect." Brooklyn, New York, John Marzulli Ryan Serhant recently spent a whopping $2.6 million in renovations on his new family townhouse in Brooklyn. Id. ISKYO ARONOV (also known as Isaac Aronov) In December 2021, he opened up in a personal essay with Today about his decision to lose weight. Under the FCA, private citizens with knowledge of fraud against the government can bring a lawsuit on behalf of the United States and share in the recovery. See, e.g., United States v. Aronov, No. (citation omitted)). 271 Cadman Plaza East Removal Hearing set for 9/11/2019 10:00 AM in Miami Division . In its opposition, the Government argues that "the Indictment is more than sufficient to put Herskowitz on notice as to those charged crimes" and "to the extent that Herskowitz complains about the quantity of evidence set forth in the Indictment, there is simply no requirement that an Indictment set forth the government's evidence, explain how it will prove the charges or allege all the specific facts that show that the defendant is guilty of the charged crimes." 28, 28(d), 32, 32(f)), in addition to 177 Lewis Avenue, (id. Herskowitz argues that he "is mentioned only a few times in the body of the Indictment, and even then, mostly by way of conclusory boilerplate allegations," (id. 1-3.) Josh's co-stars James Harris and David Parnes also made the list after they sold the most expensive home in L.A. history at a whopping $120 million. As one of the franchise's original cast members, Fredrik was a huge part of Million Dollar Listing's success. Secure .gov websites use HTTPS 74, 78 (2d Cir. The complaint alleges that the defendants Iskyo Aronov, Ron Borovinsky and Michael Konstantinovskiy ran a wide-ranging mortgage scheme to defraud the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) of the US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). 183.). Neither Aronovs attorney nor those for the three other defendants, Michael Konstantinovskiy, Tomer Dafna, and Avraham Tarshish, replied to requests for comment. Brooklyn NY 11201, Telephone: 718-254-7000 19.) Many of these homes were located in economically challenged areas of New York where affordable housing is at a premium.. Eagle file photo, News for those who live, work and play in Brooklyn and beyond, May 1 | Aronov and Konstantinovskiywere also charged in 2019. AG2 . [DAlessio] is a guy who got too big for his own britches., In an email published by Westchester County Business, DAlessio claimed: There was absolutely no fraud committed. If 25).) To the extent Herskowitz seeks to challenge the truth of the allegations in the Indictment or the sufficiency of the Government's evidence, this presents a factual question that cannot be decided on a motion to dismiss. Queens Village, New York, Michael Herskowitz These allegations alone are sufficient to satisfy Rule 7(c). The Brooklyn Daily Eagle and brooklyneagle.com cover Brooklyn 24/7 online and five days a week in print with the motto, All Brooklyn All the Time. With a history dating back to 1841, the Eagle is New York Citys only daily devoted exclusively to Brooklyn. Luis D. Ortiz released a lengthy statement on his Instagram page on Thursday following the news that Johnny Depp had won his defamation case against ex-wife Amber Heard, who claimed to be a survivor of . If convicted, the defendants each face a maximum of 30 years imprisonment and a $1 million fine. Read more of today's breaking news, here. United States Attorneys Office BROOKLYN, NY Nine homes in Brooklyn were wrapped up in a massive mortgage scam that has prompted a civil suit from the U.S. government, prosecutors announced this week. In support, the Government argues that the Indictment contains language alleging Herskowitz "assisted the Short-Sale Co-Conspirators in completing certain fraudulent short sale transactions originated by both MIP and Exclusive Homes," (id. As alleged, the defendants defrauded mortgage loan holders out of millions of dollars, with taxpayers saddled with much of the loss, Richard P. Donoghue, United States attorney for the Eastern District of New York, announced. Under the federal program, homeowners with defaulted mortgages that are insured by the Federal Housing Administration can sell their properties in a "short sale" for less than the balance of the mortgage if the sale is for fair market value. Assistant United States Attorney Tanisha Payne of the Offices Civil Division is handling forfeiture matters. Million Dollar Listing is meant to represent the top 1% trying to buy and sell houses and for this, the show needs to add some glamor from time to time. 1343 (2008); see also Fountain v. United States, 357 F.3d 250, 252 (2d Cir. Aronov appeared in court in Miami and his bond was set at $500,000, according to court papers. [1] (718) 254-6323. This Office will Eastern District of New York The partners negotiated with banks to let the property go for far less than market rate, a process known as short selling. The scam in Monday's lawsuit caused millions of dollars in damages to the Federal Housing Administration since the men would file false or. The individual defendants used various corporate entities to further their scheme. The fraud meant the men not only got the properties at below-market value, but were given broker fees and "induced lenders to release the FHA-insured mortgages at a loss.". The four other men were arraigned in Brooklyn. Contact Lukas Vrbka at [email protected]. The partners negotiated with banks to let the property go for far less than market rate, a process known as short selling. The New York Post reported last month that his firm scored its first (multi) million-dollar listing: 355 Ocean Boulevard, the largest single-family oceanfront property in Miami. (Id. 16), and that to the extent the Indictment charges him with different substantive counts of wire fraud related to specific short sale transactions, "these counts are inconsistent with the factual recitation of the Indictment," which "indicates that [Herskowitz] was not a participant in the [MIP Scheme] and that he is named only in conjunction with the alleged Exclusive Homes [S]cheme," (id. 2.6 1491. 15, 18.) 's Mem. Although investors didnt know it, he was splitting from his wife, Yvonne. See which Bravo real estate agents are returning for more high-stakes drama in the newly released season 14 trailer. Between 2013 and 2016, Aronov and his co-conspirators engaged in the "short sales" of nine homes in Brooklyn (three in Bed-Stuy and two in Bushwick) and one in Queens Village - acquiring the. 's Mem. Aronov and Konstantinovskiywere also charged in 2019. If a homeowner obtains approval for a short sale, the lender releases the mortgage after the short sale and submits an FHA insurance claim to HUD to cover the outstanding mortgage balance net of the short sale proceeds, plus approved costs and interest. He said he would cut back by no longer going to his golf club, recalled the real estate pro, who lost around $70,000. Five years ago, there seemed to be no reason for investors to doubt DAlessio. Many of these homes were located in economically challenged areas of New York where affordable housing is at a premium.. He hosted friends at his $13 million home in Water Mill, LI, to play. The defendants allegedly engaged in a scheme of wholesale deception when they provided false, misleading, and incomplete information to lending institutions, homeowners, and the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) causing millions of dollars in damages to the FHA, which typically results in higher premiums being charged to future first-time homeowners. 2018) (rejecting defendants' argument that "the indictment is deficient" for failing to "allege any facts to support its contention" that defendants knowingly made false representations to their respective universities regarding violations of NCAA rules, because the indictment sufficiently put defendants on notice of the criminal conduct alleged and the defendants' arguments otherwise amount to premature challenges to the sufficiency of the evidence). The governments complaint intervenes in a lawsuit originally brought by under thequi tam provisions of the FCA. Bond recommendation/set: Iskyo Aronov (1) $500,000.00 w/10% w/Nebbia. In April, the developer pleaded guilty to wire fraud in connection with his three-year scheme to rip off investors in luxury real estate projects. Konstantinovskiy worked as an agent for My Ideal Property, where he allegedly conspired with others to fraudulently obtain properties. Further, with respect to 1219 Jefferson Avenue, "the only mention of [him] is that he participated in the closing by wiring the loan payoff amount to the servicer's bank account," (id. The United States filed a civil complaint against three New York men accused of running a years-long mortgage scheme that defrauded the government's housing agencies, the United States Attorney for the Eastern District of New York announced. An official website of the United States government. The US Attorneys Office for the Eastern District of New York charged the men with conspiracy to commit wire fraud and bank fraud. 's Reply 1-2 (citing Ind. (Indictment ("Ind.") In May 2018, he filed Chapter 7 bankruptcy, sending eight of his properties into foreclosure. He considers his cars as his most prized possessions. Before pleading guilty to embezzling $58 million, real estate developer Michael DAlessio was the portrait of generosity. Families with children account for 61% of New York Citys unhoused people, or 34,456 of 56,334 total, according to thedaily census. Transcript may be viewed at . R. Crim. 175 VERNON AVE. INC. 308 LINDE ST. LLC. Pursuant to Rule 12(b)(3)(B) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, a defendant may move to dismiss an indictment for various defects, including "a failure to state an offense." 1996). 128(c)). P. 7(c)(1); United States v. Dupree, 870 F.3d 62, 70 (2d Cir. Now, Gold is back on the screen, as Million Dollar Listing New York season 7 airs on June 12.. Steve Gold on Million Dollar Listing New York has turned a lot of heads, and fans of the show . Herskowitz also argues that the "allegations do not show that his participation in the closings was with any kind of guilty knowledge," and instead the "factual detail in the Indictment negates any inference of even an implicit understanding [of the conspiracy]" by making clear that he "was a closing agent and nothing more, who was used by his co-Defendants rather than being a partner in crime with them." See Wey, 2017 WL 237651, at *5 ("An indictment does not 'have to specify evidence or details of how the offense was committed.'" If you would like to sponsor a notice, a photo, or an article about your favorite organization, or even wish a loved one Happy Birthday, send your content to Jennifer Hopewell, [emailprotected]. 'Million Dollar Listing' Agent Has His Own New Listing Steve Gold of the Corcoran Group is selling his fully renovated loft on Wooster Street in SoHo. 2005))); Coffey, 361 F.Supp.2d at 111 ("[T]he validity of an indictment is tested by its allegations, not by whether the Government can prove its case." In furtherance of the Exclusive Homes Scheme, Herskowitz "wired $239, 483.88 to the [mortgage loan] servicer in connection" with the short sale transaction to purchase 177 Lewis Avenue. This Office and our A federal jury in Brooklyn returned a guilty verdict today against Marvin Pippins, also known as Mukk, a member of the Brooklyn-based street gang 5-9 Brims, on counts of racketeering As alleged, Russell turned the demand for cryptocurrency investments into a scheme to defraud numerous investors in order to fund his lifestyle, stated United States Attorney Peace. Just a case of disgruntled seasoned real-estate investors with big damaged egos.. Under the FCA, private citizens with knowledge of fraud against the government can bring a lawsuit on behalf of the United States and share in the recovery. As a result, they not only acquired the properties for below-fair market value prices, but obtained broker fees in the transactions and induced lenders to release the FHA-insured mortgages at a loss, the complaint alleges. Accordingly, the Court denies Herskowitz's motion to dismiss Counts Two, Four, Six, and Seven. of Def. The L.A.-based realtors have been brutally fighting with one another for 10 seasons on Million Dollar Listing Los Angeles, but after years of watching their arguments disrupt parties, cause.

Carl Trueman Aimee Byrd, Sherwin Williams Upward Kitchen, Articles I